Warranty vs. Customer Pay: Managing Mixed Transactions

A customer comes in for warranty work, but while the car's on the lift, the tech finds additional maintenance items. Now you have one RO with two payment sources: warranty (from the manufacturer) and customer pay (from the customer).

Managing these mixed transactions correctly matters for:

• Customer clarity (they know what they're paying for)
• Manufacturer compliance (warranty documented correctly)
• Accounting accuracy (revenue properly categorized)
• Reconciliation (everything balances)

Here's how to handle it.

Understanding the Split

What Creates Mixed Transactions

Warranty + Maintenance:

• Customer in for warranty repair
• Tech recommends oil change, filters, etc.
• Warranty covers one part, customer pays other

Warranty + Declined Work:

• Some work covered under warranty
• Some work not covered
• Customer chooses to do the non-covered work

Partial Warranty:

• Manufacturer covers part of repair
• Customer responsible for rest (deductible, non-covered portion)

Why It Matters

For the customer:

• Need to understand what they're paying
• Shouldn't pay for warranty items
• Clear receipt showing breakdown

For the dealer:

• Warranty reimbursement from manufacturer
• Customer pay collected directly
• Two revenue streams, one transaction

For accounting:

• Different revenue recognition
• Different payment timing
• Different categories

Payment Processing

The Customer Pay Portion

For the portion the customer pays:

• Process like any service transaction
• Customer pays at cashier or in lane
• Posted to their account/RO
• Standard receipt provided

The Warranty Portion

For the warranty portion:

• No customer payment collected
• Claim submitted to manufacturer
• Payment received later
• Different accounting treatment

On the Receipt

Customer should see:

• Total repair cost (transparency)
• Warranty coverage (what manufacturer paid)
• Customer responsibility (what they paid)
• Net due (what they owe now)

Example:

Brake Pad Replacement      $350.00
  Covered by Warranty     -$350.00
Oil Change                  $89.95
Cabin Air Filter            $45.00
---------------------------------
Total Service              $484.95
Warranty Coverage         -$350.00
---------------------------------
Customer Total             $134.95

DMS Configuration

Splitting the RO

Most DMS platforms allow:

• Single RO with multiple pay types
• Each line item tagged (warranty, customer, internal)
• Totals calculated per pay type

Payment Association

When customer pays:

• Payment applies to customer-pay portion only
• Warranty portion remains for claim
• RO reflects correct status

Status Management

RO should show:

• Customer pay: Paid (when customer pays)
• Warranty: Pending (until claim submitted/paid)
• Or similar clear status for each portion

Cashier Workflow

Presenting to Customer

At checkout:

1. Review RO with customer
2. Show what's covered by warranty
3. Show what they're responsible for
4. Confirm customer-pay amount
5. Process payment for customer portion only

Customer Questions

"Why is my total different from the invoice?" "Part of your service is covered under warranty. You're only paying for the [maintenance items]. The [warranty items] are covered by the manufacturer."

"Can I see the warranty claim?" Provide documentation of what's submitted to manufacturer if customer requests.

"When will warranty be paid?" "The manufacturer processes warranty claims separately. That doesn't affect your bill today — you're only paying for the customer-pay items."

Accounting Treatment

Customer Pay Revenue

• Recognize at time of service/payment
• Standard service revenue
• Normal accounts receivable (if not immediate payment)

Warranty Revenue

• Recognize when claim is processed (varies by policy)
• Different revenue category
• Accounts receivable from manufacturer
• May be different timing than customer pay

Cost Allocation

Costs (parts, labor) should be:

• Allocated appropriately between warranty and customer pay
• Matched to corresponding revenue
• Tracked for profitability analysis

Reconciliation

Daily Reconciliation

For mixed ROs:

• Customer payments should match customer-pay portions
• Warranty portions shouldn't appear in customer collections
• Clear separation in reports

Warranty Claim Reconciliation

Separately:

• Track warranty claims submitted
• Match to manufacturer payments received
• Reconcile warranty AR

Common Discrepancies

Customer payment doesn't match RO:

• Was warranty portion included accidentally?
• Was discount not applied?
• Error in RO totals?

Warranty claim rejected:

• Review claim details
• May need to rebill to customer or absorb

Special Situations

Extended Warranty (Third-Party)

Not manufacturer warranty:

• Different claims process
• Different payment timing
• May require pre-authorization

Handle similarly but with appropriate party.

Goodwill Coverage

Manufacturer or dealer covers something outside warranty:

• Document as goodwill
• Different accounting treatment
• Still separate from customer pay

Deductibles

Some warranties have customer deductibles:

• Customer pays deductible
• Warranty covers rest
• Clear on receipt

Declined Warranty Items

Manufacturer rejects some items:

• Customer may become responsible
• Or dealer absorbs
• Communication with customer needed

Training Staff

Service Advisors

Should understand:

• How to write mixed ROs correctly
• What's covered vs. not covered
• How to explain to customers
• Authorization requirements

Cashiers

Should understand:

• How to read mixed RO
• Collect only customer-pay portion
• Answer basic warranty questions
• When to escalate

Accounting Staff

Should understand:

• Revenue recognition rules
• Warranty claim tracking
• Reconciliation process
• Problem resolution

Common Mistakes

Mistake: Collecting for Warranty Items

Accidentally charging customer for warranty-covered items:

• Customer overcharged
• Duplicate revenue (claim + customer)
• Customer trust damaged

Prevention: Clear RO documentation, cashier training

Mistake: Missing Customer Collection

Not collecting customer-pay portion:

• Treating everything as warranty
• Lost revenue
• AR issues

Prevention: Clear customer-pay totals, cashier verification

Mistake: Claim Errors

Warranty claim doesn't match work performed:

• Manufacturer rejects claim
• Revenue lost or delayed
• Rework required

Prevention: Accurate RO documentation, claim review

Mistake: Accounting Mix-Up

Warranty and customer-pay revenue combined:

• Financial reporting inaccurate
• Analysis distorted
• Potential compliance issues

Prevention: Clear account coding, regular review

Reporting

Track Separately

Reports should show:

• Customer-pay revenue
• Warranty revenue
• Mixed transaction frequency
• Warranty claim aging

Analysis Questions

• What percentage of ROs are mixed?
• Average customer-pay on mixed ROs?
• Warranty claim turnaround time?
• Rejection rate on claims?

Integration Considerations

Payment System Integration

Payment system should:

• Accept customer-pay amount from RO
• Not include warranty portion
• Post to correct RO/account

DMS Integration

• Payment posts to customer-pay portion
• Warranty portion status updated separately
• Clear audit trail

---

Simplify Mixed Transaction Handling →

Anchorbase integrates with your DMS to make warranty/customer-pay splits clear and payment processing accurate. No more confused reconciliations.