The True Cost of 'Free' Payment Processing for Dealerships

"Free payment processing."

It's a compelling pitch. Who wouldn't want to eliminate processing costs entirely? But in payment processing, nothing is truly free. The cost exists — it's just hidden somewhere else.

Here's what "free" actually means and what it costs you.

Understanding the "Free" Model

How It Works

"Free" processing almost always means surcharging or cash discount programs. The processor isn't waiving fees — they're helping you pass them to customers.

The mechanism:

• You pay zero (or near-zero) to the processor
• Your customers pay 3-4% extra when using credit cards
• The surcharge covers processing costs

That's not "free" — that's a cost-shifting model.

Why Processors Market It as Free

Because "free" gets attention. It's technically true that YOU don't pay processing fees. But:

• The fees still exist
• Your customers pay them
• There are costs beyond the obvious

What "Free" Really Costs

Cost #1: Customer Experience

Adding fees changes the transaction:

• Customers notice the surcharge
• Some will be annoyed
• Some will complain
• A few may go elsewhere

The question: Is saving $X worth the customer friction?

For some dealerships, yes. For others, especially in premium markets, no.

Cost #2: Competitive Position

If you surcharge and competitors don't:

• Price comparisons get complicated
• You appear more expensive
• Customers may feel nickel-and-dimed

The question: What do competitors in your market do?

Cost #3: Compliance Burden

Surcharging requires:

• Card network registration (30-day advance)
• Proper signage (entry, point of sale, receipt)
• Card-type detection (credit only, never debit)
• Rate caps (≤3%, ≤actual cost)
• State law compliance (prohibited in some states)

The question: Are you equipped to manage compliance?

Cost #4: Staff Effort

Surcharging means more customer conversations:

• Explaining the fee
• Handling complaints
• Managing exceptions

The question: How much staff time will this consume?

Cost #5: Hidden Fees

"Free" programs often have costs you don't immediately see:

• Per-transaction fees (small but present)
• Monthly minimums
• Equipment costs
• "Account maintenance" fees

The question: Is it actually free, or just marketed that way?

The Fine Print

What to Look For

When evaluating "free" processing offers:

Ask: "What fees will still appear on my statement?"

• Many programs have per-transaction fees ($0.05-$0.15 per transaction)
• These add up with volume

Ask: "What's the surcharge rate vs. my actual cost?"

• If surcharge is 3.5% but actual cost is 2.5%, where's the extra 1%?
• Some programs take margin from the surcharge

Ask: "What if I'm in a no-surcharge state?"

• Connecticut, Massachusetts, Puerto Rico prohibit surcharging
• "Free" isn't available there

Ask: "What about debit cards?"

• Can't surcharge debit
• You still pay on debit transactions
• What's that rate?

Contract Terms

Watch for:

• Long-term contracts (limits flexibility)
• Equipment leases (expensive over time)
• Termination fees (trap you in)
• Rate increase provisions (price can rise)

"Free" with a 3-year contract and $500 termination fee isn't really free.

Who "Free" Works For

Good Fit

Price-sensitive market:

• Customers accustomed to fees
• Value-oriented positioning
• Competitors already surcharging

High processing costs:

• Significant credit card volume
• Large transactions (down payments)
• Cost savings is meaningful

Operationally ready:

• Staff trained to handle surcharging
• Compliance processes in place
• Customer communication planned

Poor Fit

Premium market:

• Customers expect seamless experience
• Surcharging feels cheap
• Brand damage risk

Prohibited states:

• Connecticut, Massachusetts, Puerto Rico
• "Free" isn't an option

Limited credit card volume:

• If most payments are debit or cash, savings are minimal
• Effort not worth the benefit

Competitive disadvantage:

• If competitors don't surcharge, you look worse
• Customer comparison shopping is common

The Math: Free vs. Traditional

Scenario: $200,000 Monthly Volume

60% credit, 30% debit, 10% cash

Traditional processing (interchange-plus):

• Credit ($120K × 2.4%): $2,880
• Debit ($60K × 0.8%): $480
• Total monthly cost: $3,360

"Free" processing with surcharging:

• Credit: $0 (recovered via surcharge)
• Debit ($60K × 0.8%): $480
• Per-transaction fees (500 transactions × $0.10): $50
• Monthly fee: $25
• Total monthly cost: $555

Monthly savings: $2,805 Annual savings: $33,660

But Also Consider

• Staff time handling surcharge conversations: ???
• Customer goodwill impact: ???
• Competitive positioning effect: ???
• Compliance management: ???

The math is compelling. The intangibles require judgment.

Questions to Ask Yourself

Before choosing "free" processing:

1. How will your customers react?

• What's your customer base like?
• Are they price-sensitive or convenience-focused?
• Have you tested the reaction?

2. What do competitors do?

• Is surcharging common in your market?
• Will you be at a disadvantage?

3. Can you implement correctly?

• Do you understand compliance requirements?
• Can you train staff effectively?
• Is your equipment capable?

4. What are the real savings?

• After all fees, what do you actually save?
• Is it worth the effort and risk?

Alternatives to "Free"

If you want to reduce processing costs but "free" doesn't fit:

Negotiate Better Rates

Traditional processing with better pricing:

• Shop competitive quotes
• Leverage your volume
• Negotiate aggressively

Optimize Card Mix

Encourage lower-cost payment methods:

• Promote debit usage
• Accept ACH for appropriate situations
• Offer cash/check discounts (different from surcharging)

Hybrid Approach

Surcharge in some situations, not others:

• Large down payments: surcharge (customers understand)
• Small service tickets: absorb (not worth the friction)

Our Take

"Free" payment processing is a real option that works for some dealerships. But:

• It's not actually free — customers pay
• There are real costs beyond the fee itself
• It requires proper implementation
• It doesn't fit every market or customer base

Be skeptical of anyone who presents it as pure upside. Understand the full picture before deciding.

The best choice depends on your specific situation:

• Your market
• Your customers
• Your competitive environment
• Your operational capabilities

Making the Decision

Consider "free" (surcharging) if:

• You're comfortable with customer impact
• You can implement compliance correctly
• The savings are meaningful for your situation
• Competitors are doing it too

Stay with traditional if:

• Customer experience is paramount
• Your market would react poorly
• Compliance feels burdensome
• Savings aren't significant enough

Either way, get the full picture before committing.

---

Understand Your Real Options →

Anchorbase will show you the true cost comparison for your specific situation. No pressure, no games — just the numbers so you can make an informed decision.